English Girl in Vienna

Cultural Commentator

Cold Ones

What is it we need from other people? It is our expectations of others that cause us to feel satisfied or not with the actions of those around us. It is our expectations, often based on what we are accustomed to, which lead us to notice things and make comment. Most of my cultural observations arise from what is alien to me, what is unexpected, what I find surprising. I am amused, aghast and sometimes angered by things merely because they are different to anything I have experienced before, or,  perhaps more accurately, they are different to how I would like things to be on particular occasions.

When considering people, we often lump groups together and ascribe ‘national personality traits’; the British are punctual, reserved, stuffy, awkward, whereas Americans are loud, confident, unselfconscious. One thing I hear time and time again is that Austrians, and especially the Viennese, are cold, unkind, impolite. Perhaps those people saying this might have experienced such traits from Austrians, maybe even often enough to feel justified in ascribing this label to all of them. However, I must describe the situations in which I hear these complaints about the locals. It is in my classes. I have been asked if I like Vienna, by non-natives, and when I say I love the place they say  something along the lines of, ‘Yes, it’s a beautiful city, but it’s a shame about the people, isn’t it?’ If I defend the locals, or say I haven’t really experienced anything that negative, or start to say that people in most capital cities around the world appear cold because they are always in such a rush to get anywhere and the same is often said of Londoners, they shake their head knowingly and say, ‘Just wait. You’ll see.’ Such conversations take place in front of many Austrians, who can fully hear every negative thing being said. I once overheard an Austrian and a Czech talking and the Czech said to the Austrian, ‘Austrians are not nice people. They are very cold and not friendly.’ Understandably, the Austrian was a little lost for words. But I have to wonder why anyone would think it was ok to say that so blatantly to that Austrian person. What is nice, warm or even friendly about that? Nothing. And that’s my point: in being so rude and tactless, people become exactly what they complain about. If you’re from a culture that is superior in warmth, hospitality and openness, then why not display those qualities and not only to those who behave the same as you?

It’s easy to be around people who are the same as us; the key to surviving and even living happily in a mix of different cultures is how we manage being around people who are different. My point about the Czech student being rude to the Austrian also needs consideration because I looked at that behaviour through the eyes of someone who likes good manners at all times, whereas the Czech might value honesty in all interaction, and what I consider ‘tactful’ could also be considered ‘dishonest’. Like everything, it  depends on how you choose to look at it.

This is what came up when I typed ‘Cold Austrians’ into Google!!

Advertisements

Single Post Navigation

2 thoughts on “Cold Ones

  1. Karina Serrano on said:

    Hallo! I found your blog while looking for indian restaurants in ypenplatz .This post in particularly got me thinking about my own behavior when asked if I like Vienna.To be honest I usually lie and say yes; One day after a terrible day I was feeling frustrated and angry and answered with a no, not really. It felt liberating !! Being from Latinamerica where politeness is a heavy cultural issue I do not want to offend people of the country I am living in ( whatever the reason) yet I would have loved to have an honest conversation about the reasons.

    Maybe this kind of conversations are just for close friendships , maybe not. But what I am really sure about is that respect should always be present. We (Auslander) and Austrians need to have this present.

  2. Helle on said:

    Actually, in my experience, the Viennese ARE remarkably lacking in what is usually referred to as “warmth”. Human warmth, to be specific.

    Of course that doesn’t mean they are “bad” people (if such a ridiculous generalisation were even possible), far from it; but “warm” or even particularly polite they are not.
    Never in my life have I seen so many “buttoned up” faces, so many averted eyes (oh the averted eyes!), so many staunchly smileless faces – and I’ve been around! (I’ve also been living here in Vienna for quite a while.)
    What’s even more puzzling, they seem to be remarkably unresponsive to warmth coming from others, to eye contact, to smiles.

    In other words, I don’t think the Viennese “coldness” is a stereotype – it is , simply, the truth. And I don’t see why it shouldn’t be expressed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: